Press "Enter" to skip to content

Terror on farms continues as two are badly assaulted for fishing

The Mookgophong incident has raised questions about the rights of people suspected of trespassing and the limits of private property owners' authority. Photo Lucas Ledwaba/ Mukurukuru Media

The alleged assault of two men at a farm in Mookgophong, Limpopo, has raised serious questions about the rights of people suspected of trespassing, the use of force by private individuals and accountability when violence results in serious injury or death.

One of the men was later found dead after being taken to hospital by an unidentified person. A 50-year-old farm owner has been arrested in connection with the alleged assault, while police continue investigating the circumstances surrounding the death.

The incident happened at about 23:30 on Monday, 9 November, when two men from Phomolong Section allegedly entered a local farm intending to fish.

According to a statement issued by the South African Police Service (SAPS) in Limpopo on Thursday, 12 November, the farm owner and his son allegedly discovered the men and chased after them. They managed to apprehend one of the men, who was allegedly assaulted, while the other escaped.

Limpopo police spokesperson Brigadier Hlulani Mashaba said the man who escaped later returned to his residence and informed the victim’s family about what had happened. He reportedly told them that he did not know where his friend was.

Concerned community members later blocked a road, demanding answers about the missing man.

Police addressed the community and informed residents that the K9 Dog Unit had been called to assist with the search. Members of the K9 Unit and Public Order Policing (POPS) arrived at the scene.

Before the search could begin, police received a call from a hospital informing them that a man had been brought in by an unidentified person.

According to Mashaba, the man was reportedly said to have been hit by a motor vehicle and subsequently died. His description matched that of the missing man, and the search was called off. An inquest case was opened.

The farm owner was arrested on Wednesday, 11 November, and appeared before the Mookgophong Magistrate’s Court the following day, facing a charge of assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm (GBH).

Mashaba said: “Currently, investigations are ongoing regarding the circumstances surrounding the victim’s death.”

Police have not confirmed whether the alleged assault and the man’s death are connected. The identity of the person who took him to hospital, the circumstances of the reported vehicle collision and the medical cause of death remain important questions.

Suspected trespassing does not remove constitutional rights

While the two men were reportedly on private property without permission, the incident raises an important question: what happens to a person’s rights when they are suspected of committing an offence?

The Constitution protects everyone, including people accused of crimes. A person suspected of trespassing does not lose their right to dignity, bodily integrity or protection from violence.

Section 10 of the Constitution states that everyone has inherent dignity and the right to have their dignity respected and protected.

Section 12 protects everyone from violence, including violence from private sources. It also protects people against torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.

This is particularly relevant to allegations that a man was apprehended and assaulted by private individuals. The protection against violence is not limited to abuse by police officers or other state officials. Section 12(1)(c) specifically refers to violence from both public and private sources.

Section 8 also provides for the application of the Bill of Rights to private individuals and organisations where the nature of the right and the duty makes this applicable.

Property owners have rights too. Section 25 protects property rights, but it does not give anyone unlimited authority to punish people suspected of entering their property unlawfully.

There is a difference between protecting private property and using violence against someone suspected of trespassing. Allegations of unlawful entry should be dealt with through lawful processes, including reporting the matter to police and allowing the justice system to handle it.

The right to life, protected under section 11, is also central to the questions raised by the death. However, the cause of the man’s death and whether it was connected to the alleged assault have not yet been established.

Section 34 further protects everyone’s right to have legal disputes resolved through a fair public hearing before a court or another appropriate independent and impartial body.

These protections matter because suspected offenders are also entitled to be treated within the law. They cannot simply be subjected to punishment by individuals who believe they have committed a crime.

Investigation must establish what happened

The Mookgophong incident comes amid other cases involving people who were allegedly assaulted after being suspected of committing crimes on farms.

In February 2026, two farm security guards were arrested in the Ladybrand district of the Free State after 52-year-old Rakoro David Moloi was found dead on a farm. His brother was also found injured. Police said the two men had been accused of stealing maize. The guards were arrested on charges of murder and assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm.

In another case, two farm security guards, Kabelo Edward De Bruin and Goitsemang Piet Muller, were sentenced to 25 years’ imprisonment in September 2024 for the murder of 29-year-old Pieta Modingwana, whom they suspected of stealing watermelons on a farm near Hartswater in the Northern Cape. Modingwana was shot after being apprehended and later died in hospital.

These incidents raise similar concerns about how allegations of crime are handled and whether people suspected of wrongdoing are being protected from violence.

In Mookgophong, police have confirmed the farm owner’s arrest for assault GBH and the opening of an inquest into the man’s death. However, investigators still need to establish how the man sustained his injuries, who took him to hospital and what caused his death.

It is also important to establish what happened to the second man who was allegedly apprehended and whether he can provide further information about the incident.

The deceased man’s family deserves answers about the circumstances surrounding his death. The community also needs clarity about what happened, while the accused is entitled to a fair legal process.

Safety in farming communities must include everyone who lives and works there. Protecting property and addressing suspected crime are important, but they must happen within the law.

The Constitution does not give anyone the power to decide that another person deserves to be beaten or punished. Where violence is alleged, it must be investigated, and anyone found responsible must face the appropriate legal consequences.

SAPS Limpopo has said investigations into the circumstances surrounding the man’s death are continuing.

In 2022 the Portfolio Committee on Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development and the Portfolio Committee on Employment and Labour recently heard gruesome accounts of how white farmers are treating black workers and farm tenants.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply